British Astronomical Association
Supporting amateur astronomers since 1890

BAA Images Peter Anderson

Observation by Peter Anderson: Comparing Samyang 500mm mirror lens with...

Uploaded by

Peter Anderson

Observer

Peter Anderson

Observed

2019 Dec 01 - 00:00

Uploaded

2020 Jun 24 - 06:26

Objects

Observatory
Equipment

Equipment
  • Samyand 500mm F6.3 mirror lens, Bausch & Lomb 20" F5.6 telephoto
Exposure

Several seconds

Location

Brisbane Australia

Target name

Night view of street

Title

Comparing Samyang 500mm mirror lens with old 20" Bausch and Lomb

About this image

In the early 70'S I obtained 20" and 40" focus telephoto lenses mounted on old Graflex wooden camera boxes from the Brisbane 'Courier Mail'. The newspaper had moved to 35mm format and was disposing of all their old 'plate' cameras. I had the lenses mounted in 4" aluminium tubes with 35mm camera adaptors. Okay, it is a sacrilege to use a 'plate camera' for the very small 35mm format, but that was the way things were going. The 40" F8 Ross lens (I think this was the brand), from around the 1920's did not really produce suitable images for astrophotography and I passed it on to my friend at the Brisbane Planetarium for the same low price where he used it for some special effects.

When I had bought the 20" lens, I was told it was very good - great for photos of boating on the bay.  It is a Bausch and Lomb telephoto anastigmat 20" focal length F5.6 to F45. Over the years I have taken a number of images with it...until digital came along in the early 2000's and I was obliged to change my camera equipment from Minolta to Canon.

I recently decided to test it against a Samyang cheapie 500mm F6.3 mirror lens, having now mounted a Canon adaptor on it. I used a Canon 70D with the ASP-C sized sensor for both images - This small size is a further insult to a large plate lens. The tests, (at 5.6 full aperture for the B&L and F6.3 for the Samyang,) image an area of roadway cresting a hill 1.9km distant and show that the old lens performs very well, but the lens system is subject to flaring. 

Files associated with this observation
Like this image
Copyright of all images and other observations submitted to the BAA remains with the owner of the work. Reproduction of work by third parties is expressly forbidden without the consent of the copyright holder. By submitting images to this online gallery, you grant the BAA permission to reproduce them in any of our publications.