Observation by Peter Anderson: Comparison 150mm achromat and ED instrum...

Uploaded by

Peter Anderson


Peter Anderson


2020 Apr 04 - 23:30


2020 Apr 13 - 02:53


The Moon

  • 150mm F8 Achromat and ED instrument

2000 ISO


Brisbane, Australia

Target name



Comparison 150mm achromat and ED instruments

About this image

Comparison with 5X Barlow lens of Achromat image (on left) and ED (on right). Images 7th January 2020  for the achromat and 5th April 2020 for the ED. - Each around 09hrs 30min UT.

Files associated with this observation
Like this image
Grant Privett
Grant Privett, 2020 Apr 13 - 21:34 UTC

Have you considered doing the same type of test but comparing an achromatic image with an achromatic image taken while using a narrow band filter such as a hydrogen alpha - I wonder if, for a near colourless object like the moon, that might yield as good a result as with the ED as all the light will be brought to a single focus. 

Just a thought.

Peter Anderson
Peter Anderson, 2020 Apr 13 - 23:48 UTC

You are quite possibly correct but my filters are limited to the usual range of colours plus a couple extra. I know some owners of achromats get very acceptable results from monochrome images but the blue haze would still be over the brighter features like Aristachus in this instance so would entail tweaking in contrast. (Probably anyone who can afford a Ha filter would likely afford an ED in the first place!)

My main field is lunar occultations and this was a secondary, no tertiary instrument. I am getting too old and crotchety to put up with too much.  So when the price of the ED came down considerably I got management approval, sold the old 150mm and replaced it with the ED. So even if I wanted to perform the experiment.....

But, seriously, thanks for you interest and suggestion. Perhaps other members have some experience in this.

Copyright of all images and other observations submitted to the BAA remains with the owner of the work. Reproduction of work by third parties is expressly forbidden without the consent of the copyright holder. By submitting images to this online gallery, you grant the BAA permission to reproduce them in any of our publications.