Observation by Grant Privett: 12P

Uploaded by

Grant Privett

Observer

Grant Privett

Observed

2024 Jan 19 - 18:10

Uploaded

2024 Jan 20 - 18:19

Objects

12P Pons-Brooks

Equipment
  • 300mm VX12 f/4 Newtonian
  • SX Trius 694
  • SW NEQ6 + Rowan
Exposure

34x 30s x2 binning

Location

Near Salisbury

Target name

12P

Title

12P

About this image

As expected, stacking these images with Starlink satellites and a stiff sky gradient - not that high and Moon up - wasn't easy. It seemed to be a choice between no Starlinks and a lower SNR 12P or some 12P residual and a half decent SNR for 12P. I used a manual align option plus a Sigma+Sum in the end.

This is a compromise. Each pixel is 1.58 arc secs across.

Files associated with this observation
Like this image
Comments
Nick James
Nick James, 2024 Jan 21 - 09:08 UTC

Grant - Nice image but stacking on comets shouldn't be that hard! Astrometrica is a great tool for this with the benefit that you can get astrometry and photometry at the same time. Astrometrica stacks on the predicted ephemeris offset of the comet so there is no need for manual alignment. 

Grant Privett
Grant Privett, 2024 Jan 21 - 11:12 UTC

The fun was that thin cloud was going through and changing transparency fast. Also, it was reflecting Moonlight and causing sky gradients that varied from frame to frame. Plus, it was near the horizon over a sports field - so floodlights.

Median stacking struggled to give an ideal result as the effective gain changes and the global sky count went up and down like  yoyo - messing up the assumption on which it works. Sigma only did slightly better. I can think of ways round this (I think AA8 is doing one of them but not both) which will add nothing in good conditions but may help rescue data like this.

On Astrometrica. I have a licence somewhere ,but the config file I made for using it when using my old Newt+SXV7 never worked and I was never able to establish why.   :)

I used the manual option for the stacking because I was simultaneously checking that AstroArt was rejecting all the images with poor guiding and where satellites went near the comet - apart from Starlinks I was unlucky enough to find 2 other satellites went right over the comet itself. Its probably my most satellite polluted run of all time. Yeah, I should have just platesolved the frames.

 

Copyright of all images and other observations submitted to the BAA remains with the owner of the work. Reproduction of work by third parties is expressly forbidden without the consent of the copyright holder. By submitting images to this online gallery, you grant the BAA permission to reproduce them in any of our publications.