Wynne Corrector Problem

› Forums › Imaging › Wynne Corrector Problem

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #643987
    Martin Mobberley
    Participant

    My first attempt to upload this was labelled as Spam!
    I’m wondering if anyone on the Forum has any experience with the huge 3″ Wynne Correctors marketed by Orion Optics for their AG series?
    In 2025 I ordered an Orion Optics AG12 Newtonian. It eventually arrived after almost a year, despite a delivery estimate of a few months!
    During the last two months, when clear skies allowed, I have battled with trying to get the Wynne corrector to sensor spacing right.
    This is stated as 79mm +/-1mm. I have adjusted the spacing from about 72mm to 86mm in roughly 1mm increments over six rather stressful evenings.

    All show the same comet-like V-shaped comatic stars outside the central quarter-degree of a 1.2 x 0.8 degree field. These comatic stars are
    always the same shape with the two-pronged ‘tail’ pointing towards the centre of the image. Replies from OO take a while, but they have simply offered to sell me an adjuster to adjust and lock the spacing easily. But I don’t think this will help. I think the corrector is faulty..
    I cannot see any way to remove the corrector from the focuser. They seem to be locked together!
    In the last day or so my e-mails to OO have bounced, as if they are Spam! Unless things change I am tempted to remove the entire, massive, OO 3″
    focuser and 3″ Wynne corrector and put a cheaper 2″ focuser and corrector in place….. But maybe someone on this Forum has had the same
    issues with OO’s Wynne corrector and has some better advice? Example of a typical image attached…. 6200MM sensor.

    Martin

    #643989
    William Bristow
    Participant

    Hi Martin

    I only recently gave away an AG8 that was originally supplied with a different focuser and mounting system for the Wynne corrector (FLI Atlas focuser).

    Orion Optics have supplied the AG series with several different focusers over the production life, apart from the FLI Atlas that used a special adaptor with rather precarious nylon bolts on a sliding sleeve to attach the Wynne corrector to the focuser, most of the other focuser options used an internal thread at the mouth of the focuser draw tube that accepts the external thread at the output end of the Wynne corrector, with the entire length of the Wynne corrector sitting inside the focuser draw tube.

    You could try using a non-marring canvas or rubber Boa wrench (oil-filter wrench) to unscrew the Wynne corrector from the focuser draw tube after warming the draw tube with a hair-dryer.

    The 79mm +/- 1mm back focus distance to the camera sensor is measured from the centre of the surface of the rearmost element of the Wynne corrector.

    Although I had many other issues with the AG8 I did not have the severe coma in my images that your attachment shows but the biggest sensor I used on the AG8 was an APS-C sized sensor (28.4mm diagonal).

    If the BF distance is varied over the distances you tried, did the shape, direction or length of the ‘V’ tails change, as you would expect as you position the sensor either side of the specified BF?

    The tolerance on BF with the fast ratio optics of the AG series is incredibly tight, my AG8 and Wynne corrector needed fine tuning in 0.1mm steps to get round stars in the corners, even with the relatively small APS-C sensor that I was using, but you could see very clearly that the shape of the corner stars were changing quite significantly with very small changes to the BF.

    If you can see no visible change to the shape, length and direction of ‘V’ artefacts in test images at either side of the specified 79mm +/-1mm BF and you can’t unscrew the Wynne corrector from the focuser I’d be tempted to take it back to Orion Optics and have the primary mirror and the Wynne corrector bench tested with their Zygo interferometer.

    William.

    #643991
    Martin Mobberley
    Participant

    Many thanks William,

    This is extremely useful advice for me. How did you adjust in 0.1mm steps? Did OO make you a device to do this?
    The V shaped coma does not change shape at all however small or large the spacing. This makes me think the Wynne corrector is faulty.
    Orion did supply a Zygo plot for the mirror, but there was no test data for the Wynne corrector.
    I am indeed measuring the 79mm from the centre of that rearmost lens.

    Thanks again,
    Martin

    #643992
    Peter Carson
    Participant

    Hi Martin,
    I have no experience with the Wynne corrector, but I do own and have used a Planewave 0.66x focal reducer. See https://planewave.com/products/reducer-0-66x-cdk12-5-14-17/. This reducer is huge and requires spacing within the optical train to within millimetre accuracy. Anything more than ±0.5 mm and the image-plane spot size deteriorates significantly. I guess it’s the same for a coma corrector.
    See the attached plot of image spot size vs reducer position.

    Peter

    #643994
    William Bristow
    Participant

    I used a set of M48 Delrin spacer washers Martin.

    Initial distance was set at 80mm (using 3.0mm thick filters in the Filter Wheel at that time) using a vernier, and then after evaluating the images I needed to add another 1.2mm BF by adding 1x1mm x 48mm and 2×0.1mm x 48mm Delrin spacer washers between the filter wheel and the camera.

    The BF distance of 79mm that Orion Optics quote is the ‘native’ distance with no filters in the optical path, you have to add ~1/3rd the thickness of the filters to the BF on the camera side of the FW, and then there’s the thickness of the camera window too that needs accounting for.

    The AG8 was being used in Portugal at that time and I think I bought a pack of Delrin 48mm spacer rings from TS in Germany for a few Euro’s. Fiddly and time consuming but very rigid and inexpensive. It’s really a one-time operation so no need for an expensive adjustable coupler, unless changing cameras and filters regularly IMO.

    The worrying thing with your Wynne corrector tests is that there should be a very obvious change in the shape of the corner stars on either side of the nominal BF distance, your results are abnormal.

    Maybe I was just lucky and had the distance almost correct from the off, I certainly didn’t use more than +/- 2.00 mm spacers either side of the 80mm I calculated when fine-tuning the BF distance.

    William.

    #643996
    Martin Mobberley
    Participant

    Many thanks Peter,
    Interesting that even a Planewave reducer/corrector is so fussy about spacing!

    Martin

    #643997
    Martin Mobberley
    Participant

    Many thanks for this extra information William, esp. wrt filters. I suspected these would affect things but imagined I would still be able to get to the sweetspot without such a battle….

    Yes indeed, the lack of a change of shape in the comatic stars as I pass through the nominal BF distance is very odd. As I understand it most comatic stars change from radial (comet-like) to tangential (seagull-like) as one passes thru the correct back focus….. Not for me with this corrector!

    Also, my field of view at the nominal distance corresponds to 300mm f/4 as if the corrector is 1.0x not 0.95x. If the Wynne corrector has not been assembled correctly this might explain things.

    Hopefully Orion Optics might respond with a positive solution soon!

    Martin

    #643998
    Denis Buczynski
    Participant

    Martin, Sorry to hear of your problems with the OO AG12 and corrector. It seems tO me that the corrector is faulty, no mattter what you try it is not working, So I would return the corrector and focuser to OO and demand a refund for the value of those parts. Get a commercial focuser and corrector and fit these and get observing again. You do not want or need to spend more of your observing time messing with faulty optics. The OTA will probably work well in it original Newtonian congfiguration , it just needs a working focuser and corrector. These are available off the shelf. I use a 12 f/4 OO Newtonian and a Baader coma corrector and in combination they produce very acceptable images. You can be up and running in a week or so if you take the OO focuser and corrector off and return it.
    Best wishes
    Denis

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.